CHAIR OF REBUILD AMERICA'S SCHOOLS TESTIFIES
ON LEGISLATION FOR SCHOOL MODERNIZATION NEEDS
Testimony of Robert P. Canavan, Chair, Rebuild
America's Schools
before
The Committee on Ways and Means
U.S. House of Representatives
March 21, 2001
Thank you for the opportunity to address the Committee
in the context of the President's revenue provisions. Rebuild America's
Schools recognizes the President's emphasis on education in his budget
and revenue proposals. Leaving No Child Behind is the goal and
objective of public education. We believe parents, school boards,
educators, and community leaders in urban, rural and suburban school
districts across America are committed to meet the President's
challenge.
Rebuild America's Schools also supports the President's
call for accountability. Schools boards, teachers, parents and students
are ready to be accountable. But, as we call for greater
accountability, we should also make sure that the students'
workplace-where he or she is performing and being accountable-is a
safe, modern learning environment.
We need to give students the classrooms that will help
them succeed. A clean, safe, modern classroom is more likely to help a
child succeed than a dark, overcrowded, hot or cold, under-equipped
classroom built for the 1950's not the 21st Century.
We read an interesting parallel in the Wall Street
Journal of March 19th about Treasury Secretary O'Neill's concern for
safe working environments. Secretary O'Neill is quoted that his focus
on worker safety and worker relations " …is a precondition for
beginning to get people to believe that you care about them and that
they matter as human beings." Our coalition asks what is the message we
are giving to America's students if they are not provided clean, safe,
up to date work environments in their schools?
Rebuild America's Schools thanks Congresswoman Johnson
and Congressman Rangel for the leadership they are providing on the
important issue of school facilities. Their "America's Better
Classrooms Act" will give local communities a tool to finance modern
schools to help students meet the President's challenge.
Rebuild America's Schools: $ 268 billion Necessary to
Modernize Schools Rebuild America's Schools is a national coalition of
education organizations, school boards and districts, PTAs,
architects-- all helping local communities find the resources to give
their children modern classrooms.
Rebuild America's Schools Coalition was organized in
1997 in response to the 1996 Government Accounting Office Study
documenting the national cost to renovate and repair school building at
$ 112 billion. Communities across the country knew they were struggling
at the local level to find the resources to finance school repairs and
renovations. The GAO study documented that schools in every state were
in need of repair and modernization.
Since the GAO study in 1996 subsequent reports placed
the estimates for school repair even higher. In 1999 the National
Center for Education Statistics estimated repair costs at $127 billion.
A study by the National Education Association projected the cost of
renovating, repairing schools and building new schools, for rising
student enrollments, to be $268 billion. This need was documented again
in the recently released report of the American Society of Civil
Engineers grading federal support for infrastructure. Schools again
received the lowest grade, D-.
The American Institute of Architects estimates that
thousands of schools- all across the nation in urban and rural schools
are in desperate need of repair. Nearly, 60 percent of the schools need
either new roofs, plumbing or heating systems, or electrical power and
lighting systems. Many of these schools were built nearly 50 years ago
and most cannot accommodate growing enrollments. The AIA also estimates
that 36 percent of schools use portable classrooms. There are at least
16,000 portable classrooms in use in Florida. More than 2 million
California school children attend classes in portable classrooms.
The need is real.
California: One State's Student Enrollments as an
Illustration
The California Federal School Infrastructure Coalition supports Rebuild
America's Schools. Cal-Fed has written to the Committee on this issue
and I will use their information to illustrate one state's school
construction situation. Every state faces the same problems to
differing degrees.
The California Department of Finance estimates that California's
student population will grow by an average of 37,653 pupils per year
between 2000-2005. Currently, California has a K-12 student population
of approximately 5,951,612 students. Projections are that by the year
2005, California will have a student population base of 6,134,412
students.
In 1998 California voters passed Proposition 1A that
provided state funds for modernization and new construction. The state
funding from the proposition requires a match from local school
districts. The entire $2.1 billion has been apportioned to school
districts and there is a pending project list totaling over $1 billion.
These state funds were intended to last through 2002.
Despite this investment, the additional need for
deferred maintenance and modernization in California over the next five
years is estimated conservatively at $7 billion while new school
construction needs are estimated to exceed $ 9.6 billion. To illustrate
these costs, a 1999 estimate placed the cost of a 600-student
elementary school at $7.75 million in California. A 1,000-student
middle school would cost $13.75 million and a 2,000-student high school
would cost $ 36 million if not higher. Many communities in California
will have to build more than one elementary school, more than one
middle school and more than one high school per year.
School districts and voters in California are struggling
to provide the resources to meet these documented needs. Federal
support does help. California has succefully used the Qualified Zone
Academy Bond program (QZAB) to renovate, repair, and reform programs
helping to create innovative and model schools.
As of January 2001 California has fully allocated the
QZAB allocations for 1998, 1999, 2000, and 2001 totaling approximately
$222,488,000. Local districts have requested an additional $85,000,000
for QZAB projects. Some of the successful QZAB projects include a
Technology Academy in the Pomona Unified School District, the Center
for Advanced Research and Technology in the Clovis and Fresno Unified
School districts, and two Computer Certification Academies in the
Baldwin Park Unified School District. An extension or expansion of the
QZAB program would be quickly utilized in California and other states
as well.
In addition to California, QZABS are being used in 23 of
the 25 states represented by members of the Ways and Means Committee.
State and local governments are trying to provide the
school facilities that will Leave No Child Behind. But, state and local
resources cannot address the magnitude of the problem. There is a role
for the federal government. The federal government supports
transportation, and science--areas of national interest. Maintaining
our public schools and providing students safe schools and classrooms
is in the national interest.
Congresswoman Johnson and Congressman Rangel and members
of this committee on both sides of the aisle have introduced HR 1076
the America's Better Classrooms Act. This bill will use an estimated
federal investment of $2.7 billion over 5 years to leverage almost $25
billion in local school construction bonds. This is a frugal and wise
investment.
In the 106th Congress 231 members of the House
cosponsored the America's Better Classrooms Act. We expect a clear
bipartisan majority of the House to again support this legislation.
Providing students the decent, modern classrooms they need to learn and
succeed is an issue that should unite members from both sides of the
aisle.
As this Committee addresses the issue of tax reduction,
Rebuild America's Schools believes Mrs. Johnson's and Mr. Rangel's bill
provides local property tax relief. Local communities are constantly
struggling to balance local tax rates with the need to modernize
existing schools and to build new schools. The America's Better
Classrooms Act uses a tax credit in lieu of interest to support local
community efforts to finance school construction bonds. The interest
saved through the Johnson Rangel tax credit over the life of the
typical school bond will lessen the burden of local property tax
necessary to finance the bond.
School Modernization Tax Credits: Local Decision Making
The school modernization bonds in the America's Better
Classrooms Act provide a federal tax credit in lieu of interest. The
responsibility for the bond principal is with the states and local
communities. At the same time, all decision-making prerogatives related
to the actual school renovation and construction remains a local
community decision. The federal government provides an interest subsidy
while leaving the decisions about the construction of the schools at
the local level. The Johnson Rangel bill allocates the credits to the
states through the Treasury Department. States then make
sub-allocations to school districts. That is the extent of the federal
involvement. Decisions about where to build, how to build and what to
build are made at the local level.
Private Activity Bonds: One of a Menu of Options
The President has proposed private activity bonds as a
means to address the nation's school facility problems. We appreciate
that this proposal recognizes the need for federal support for local
school districts. Private activity bonds, which require the
participation of a developer, can be used by some school districts.
Some school districts may be able to find such a partner. But, other
districts will not. Many more will have difficulty finding the
resources through their operating funds to pay the required lease fees.
For example, in California, school districts do not have the revenue
source to make lease payments to a developer constructing a school
through private activity bonds.
Many rural schools will have difficulty finding a
developer to build a school with private activity bonds. Rebuild
America's Schools and Organization Concerned About Rural Education
(OCRE) estimate that one out of every two public schools in America is
located in a rural area or small town. Thirty eight percent of
America's students go to schools in rural areas. Forty-one percent of
public school teachers work in rural schools. Rural communities will
have difficulty using the private activity bonds.
If combined with Mrs. Johnson's and Mr. Rangel's school
modernization bonds private activity bonds could be part of a menu of
federal options available to help school districts address their
pressing school construction needs.
Conclusion
Rebuild America's Schools appreciates the attention the
Ways and Means Committee is giving to the issue of federal support for
local community efforts to modernize schools. The Committee included
some components of the America's Better Classroom Act in the tax bill
passed last year. Rebuild America's Schools asks the Ways and Means
Committee to include the America's Better Classrooms Act school
modernization bonds and the QZAB extension in addition to the private
activity bond proposal in your education tax package this year.
Students need and deserve safe, modern classrooms to
achieve the standards called for by the President.
|